InsightDS·182

Comfort narrows what writers can say

from Logan Macnair

Without hard experiences like war or whaling, comfortable modern writers fall back on writing about themselves as young city dwellers. The work loses touch with the big questions of life, death and God, small-g and capital-G, that animate the classics.

Where it appears 1

Connections

Themes and ideas

More insights from this episode

  • The itch Amazon can't scratch

    Even a purely functional purchase leaves us faintly disappointed, because without admitting it we want it to be more than it is. The itch has a completely different cause, and the letdown…

  • Stillness is now frightening

    The black screen between Netflix episodes, where you briefly see your own reflection and ask 'what am I doing?', has become one of the scariest moments for many people. Streaming has nearly…

  • Distraction's crash is existential dread

    Like any addiction, the dread on the comedown is as deep as the distraction was high. Distracting yourself less brings a more unified sense of who you are and your place in the world.

  • Extremists sell an answer to malaise

    Effective extremist propaganda doesn't deny young people's pain. It says 'your feelings are real and valid' and then supplies a reason and a group to blame, turning private emptiness into a…

  • Terrorists who walk among us

    Many people 'terrorize' their families, workplaces or industries without making the news, out of the same troubled roots as extremists: a repressed or badly integrated shadow. Logan agrees…

  • Nobody is born a neo-Nazi

    To depict extremists honestly you have to show why people join. The path usually starts with self-discovery and legitimately good advice about accountability. The poison only comes later…